Privacy & Individual Rights
Commerce, Security, & the Law
Net Culture, Art, & Literature
International Affairs & National Security
Ethics, Rhetoric, & Metaphysics
Science Fiction Other Resources
Other Book Review Sites
|Editor Benjamin M. Compaine structures the debate over the
gap in access to computers in general, and the Internet in particular, along
the lines of the age-old argument one often hears between siblings.
Yes it is.
The first set of essays have scads of tables, numbers and statistics, graphs and charts. It makes a pretty compelling argument if you can make any sense of it. It is dry reading, so bring your own water bottle.
No it's not.
A much more entertaining series of ethnographic studies, history,
anecdotal evidence and politics. It's much easier on the mind. Depending on one's viewpoint, it may be less convincing or more convincing than the first set or arguments. It's more about why we should do nothing than anything else. In short, kick back with Coke and popcorn, enjoy yourself, and let the market take care of it.
YES, it IS!
More graphs. More charts. More numbers. Some ideas about what to do. It documents efforts to wire schools and libraries in rural and urban districts and makes a good case that better access has real results.
NO, it's NOT!
This argument does have one good point: the Internet is moving too fast for public policy to get ahead or even track close behind. The pre-tech stock crash time-frame does affect the optimism of the essay's authors. In the post-bubble economy, it is not wholly convincing that the market will serve the public interest.
The Digital Divide is a seminal work, no doubt. Anyone wanting a good background for understanding telecommunications policy should read it. One thing that does bother me is that, in laying out both the yes and no arguments, the authors continue to state and restate the obvious. Poor people have less access. No kidding!
In ivory towers where the air is thin, academics debate whether the divide exists. Here on the ground, on the salary of a working man rather than the options-inflated remuneration of the digiterati, it's pretty clear. There is a digital divide. Computers in libraries and classrooms have helped, but as a society, we have a long way to go. Would that The Digital Divide provided a better road map.